by J. Brown
The continued rise of Instagram-influenced yoga has led to a new wave of criticism among East-Indians and academics alike. Accusations of cultural appropriation are being levied just as long-held myths are being debunked. Many earnest practitioners find themselves confused by the discord between what they see and read in the media and the experience they have of Yoga in their lives.
I traveled to India in 1998. I spent three months there. I did not go to study or stay in an ashram. I went with no plan. Just a backpack, a Let’s Go travel guide, and the hope that somewhere along the journey I might gain insight enough to decide whether or not to continue Yoga as a life path or seek another direction for my livelihood. I had only one condition: stay off of the tourist track. And I definitely learned something important about Yoga from my time in India. Things I could never have learned from my previous two years of practice and training in New York City.
Aspects of yoga seemed to pervade the culture of India, in stark contrast to Yoga’s obscure status back home in the US. I remember a conversation with a rare English-speaking local and the realization that many of my friends in NY who were attending Kirtan regularly and, on some level considered themselves devotees of Kali, would never be permitted in the Kali temple in India. No amount of chanting or sari and bindi-wearing can get around the fact of one’s birth or the view commonly held in India that one cannot convert to Hinduism. I also remember how many times I sought out the local teacher of a small village only to discover a string of frauds and touts, capitalizing on the naivete of tourists.
There is a renewed and legitimate debate happening over whether or not westerners have a right to take ownership of yoga in the ways that we have.
Even among westerners, there is a feeling that something is not right about a twenty-something blonde girl with a large Instagram following saying “Namaste” to promote her lifestyle brand. Then, you have folks like David Gordon White and other scholars who, in response to all the hype and co-opting, are uncovering untold truths about the history of yoga that have previously been shrouded in lore and mystery. Throw in the rampant commercialization and use of yoga as a marketing demographic across the globe and we end up with a whole lot of questions and sour grapes.
I’m having conversations with talented yoga teachers who are questioning whether to abandon teaching altogether. They are feeling like they don’t fit into what “yoga” has become. They are even embarrassed to tell people that they are yoga teachers because they don’t want to be associated with what people think of yoga teachers outside inner yoga circles. I am also being confronted with a storm of comments on Facebook calling into question my associations and accusing me of being part of an imperialist takeover of Yoga’s indigenous roots.
Truth is, yoga was first marketed and sold to the west by the same venerated teachers that are now cited as the only vestiges of authentic tradition.
The use of yoga to promote or sell things is nothing new. Mr Iyengar had students perform on Martha Stewart to promote his book sales. Mr. Pattabhi Jois travelled around the world conducting large-scale yoga events, same as the yoga celebrities of today. These guys were selling yoga just as much as they were practicing and teaching it. Granted, they were of Indian descent. Maybe that gives them more of a right to monetize yoga. But is it really that different? Or are we merely experiencing the results of macro changes in technology and economics?
I was taught that in order for my yoga to be authentic it needs to adapt to my individual needs and be specific to my cultural background. But perhaps there is a point where the practice is taken so far away from its origins that it ceases to be true to what it is. When does something become true to you but not to where you got it from? Unless, of course, you are of the view that the intention is for it to be true to the individual and not to any particular teacher, tradition or ideal.
Krishnamacharya did what he had to do to make a way for himself and his family. This takes nothing away from the gifts he has given to countless human beings.
Regardless of where we might land on the cultural appropriation and commercialization of yoga, there are people across the world who, by themselves and gathering in small and big groups, are doing breathing and moving exercises. They are doing this not as merely a form of fitness, but as a vital part of their self-care. The experiences they are having are genuinely helpful. These practices are often pivotal in people making changes in themselves and their lives that are deeply meaningful and important.
Another remembrance from my time in India is that some things are universal and transcend cultures. The gesture of placing my hands together in prayer at my chest, sometimes referred to as “Namaste,” was like an express-pass to shared humanity. I’ve found this true in other parts of the world I have traveled to as well. Simple and undeniable is the thread of wonder that runs through all beings. No amount of capitalism or appropriation can touch the warmth and love we know in our hearts.
J. Brown is a yoga teacher, writer and founder of Abhyasa Yoga Center in Brooklyn, NY. His writing has been featured in Yoga Therapy Today, the International Journal of Yoga Therapy, and across the yoga blogosphere. Visit his website at jbrownyoga.com
- The Mega Yoga Dilemma
- On Yoga Extremism
- Yoga’s Diversity Backlash: A Conversation On Including Others (Meaning Everyone) And Creating New Norms
J. Brown. Namaste! & Sat Nam! This topic deeply interests me, and I appreciate what you write here. I practice Kundalini Yoga and Meditation as taught by Yogi Bhajan. I think authenticity is a quality that demands conscious consideration in everything we do. Authenticity is one of the beads on that human thread of wonder; it takes practice; it takes strength; it takes consciousness. I appreciate what Yogi Bhajan taught that one should “learn by blessing rather than learning by questioning.” So, here goes: Bless the Capitalists. Bless the Imperialists. Bless the forefathers of Yoga. Bless those who worship Kali. Bless the yoga scholars. Bless yoga practitioners, yoga masters, and yoga beginners. Bless the users on Instagram. Bless yoga. Bless yoga tradition. Bless yoga transformation. Bless you. Bless me. Thank you for helping me clear up my mind and heart reflecting on these ideas. Sat Nam!
I totally agree with you mr. brown, I also do Yoga daily and found out that it is not just a physical exercise but it involves so many things, but not what people think about it. Market and business has made it a commercial commodity and we all are falling prey for it.
Vi o filme a “lista de Sc,2;dler”nhdemais,i30;esse livro parece interessante mesmo ,como vocÃª explicou,mas sou manteiga derretida para ler sobre a dor dos outros como vocÃª disse tem que preparar o coraÃ§Ã£o e estomago.Bjs
Amazing blog posted.
Don’t worry. Yoga’s been dominated by spiritual pimps and whores since time immemorial. Spread your wings AND your legs! And smile. Wheeeeeeeeeeeeeee!!
Thanks for the Great Article! It is important to learn and practice yoga techniques under the supervision of a trained. follow yoga tips on yoga conference.
Yoga Instructor Course
Who cares! Stop beating the ‘I went to India’ drum. Yoga has passed you by and you can’t let it go.
I had the same thoughts before deciding to practice yoga. It’s the same with the Christian religion–I cannot count with my ten fingers and ten toes just how many people want to go to Italy to visit churches, and pay so much to see them. But it gives them some sort of peace and deepens their devotion. This need to have a physical/spiritual practice, to most, if not all, is a basic need, and despite all the capitalism and marketing and business what-have-yous, the person has found a sense of fulfillment. That’s what makes yoga and other such activities authentic: the person, who recognizes the importance of yoga in his or her life in all aspects, has found something that has made him or her closer to their god or themselves. That’s the beauty of it. Yeah, yoga classes cost an arm and a leg but I get benefits that cost way more in the long run. So… yeah… talking a lot now. haha. Great article. bye!