≡ Menu
YogaDork

Let’s Forget About ‘Hip-Openers’ (PART 2)

in Practice, YogaDork Ed

pigeon-pose-hip-openerby Jennifer Rawlings

Welcome to Part 2 of my hip-opening article! In Part 1 we looked at how classifying a small, specific group of yoga poses as “hip-openers” overlooks the anatomical fact that nearly all yoga poses are hip-openers, and if we treated them that way, our practice could offer us so much more. We’ll now turn our biomechanical eye to how you can shift your alignment to truly open your hips in your practice!

How to Open Your Hips (Really)

Let’s take pigeon pose. Single-leg pigeon pose is what most yogis picture when it comes to hip-opening (although we now know that there are a multitude of other poses which open the hips as well). This is a tricky pose because it requires a range of motion in the front hip that most people don’t actually have. In order to move into the shape, we often unknowingly destabilize other joints (especially the front knee), which is just a lame situation that no one wants. In order to effectively open our hip in this pose, without putting other body parts at risk, most of us will have to prop our front thigh up very high – but few people actually do this.

I think I’ll elaborate on this whole topic in a separate blog post, but for now, I’ll just offer that full lying face-down single-leg pigeon pose isn’t a great hip opener for most chair-sitting bodies (and it wasn’t a great hip-opener for me when this photo was taken awhile back – heh heh.) For truly effective and non-joint-damaging hip-opening I’d recommend other stretches instead, like the awesome reclined pigeon pose (pictures below).

Reclined pigeon stretches a few muscles in the back of the hip, but let’s focus on just one of its main target muscles to keep things simple: the infamously tight piriformis.

As I wrote about in my hamstring stretching post (with cool rubber band photos to illustrate ), in order to stretch a muscle, the distance between the muscle’s attachment points must increase. Most people simply don’t understand how to truly move a muscle’s attachment points away from each other (I didn’t fully comprehend this myself until I studied with my biomechanics teacher, guys!) and they, therefore, end up completely bypassing their intended stretch, stretching inappropriate tissue instead.

piriformis-pelvis

The pear-shaped piriformis attaches from the front of your sacrum, which is part of your pelvis, to a prominence on the femur called the greater trochanter. In order for this muscle to stretch, the pelvis and femur must move away from each other, which means that your pelvis must be un-tucked. If your pelvis stays tucked when you’re stretching your piriformis, your pelvis and femur have moved as a unit as opposed to moving away from each other, which means that a stretch didn’t happen in the place you thought it did. I’m not exaggerating when I say that 99% of the yogis I see stretch their piriformis this way, which means they’re not stretching their hip at all. (Sad face!)

Here’s a quick review of a tucked vs. un-tucked pelvis. In the un-tucked photo, note the presence of the natural inward curve of the lumbar spine/low back.

tuck-untuck-pelvis

The below photo demonstrates the way most yogis do reclined pigeon. Knowing what we know about how to spot an un-tucked vs. tucked pelvis, can you see that in this pose, the pelvis is tucked, and instead of the natural inward curve of the lumbar spine, you see a lumbar spine that is rounded outward? There is no piriformis stretch happening in this pose at all because this muscle’s attachment points are not moving away from each other. Instead, the whole pelvis is tipped backward, resulting in an unintended stretch to the low back and a piriformis that unhappily kept its same old short length.

ankle-to-knee-dont

In this photo, however, you can see that Anna has backed off the shape by not pulling her thigh in toward her chest, which has allowed her pelvis to remain un-tucked. Now all she needs to do is maintain the un-tuck and maybe move her pigeon leg knee away from her a bit to actually create a stretch in her hip.

ankle-to-knee-do

Although the pose in this second photo might not look as “deep” as the first one, if you train your eyes to actually see what the bones are doing in a stretch, you should see that this arrangement is the only version in which the hip is actually stretching. (For the record, Anna is actually quite flexible, and she and a small percentage of flexi-types might be able to pull their thigh in a bit closer to their body and still keep an un-tucked pelvis, but no one should pull their thigh in as close as the first photo. To keep an aligned pelvis, your tailbone needs to stay firmly planted on the ground. Your thigh can pull in a bit as long as your tailbone keeps contact with the ground. Make sense?)

Other Poses

There are so many other poses which can open our hips, but to cover this topic in full is too big a job for this little old blog post. As I mentioned above, all hamstring stretches are hip-openers, and you can use the alignment tips I offer in my hamstring stretching post for all of your hamstring-openers (including parsvottanasana – pyramid pose, adho mukha svanasana – downward facing dog, and supta padangusthasana – reclined strap stretch). All seated yoga poses are also hip-openers, all backbends are hip openers, all standing poses are hip-openers – the list is practically endless! Your whole yoga practice can become a hip-opening practice if you can see these poses for what they’re actually offering to your body.

Biomechanics and anatomy offer a profound understanding of the body and what our yoga practice is offering to us. As a progressive yoga teacher, my hope is to bring the clarity of this biomechanical perspective to the way we practice yoga so that we can move toward living in our bodies in a truly mindful way. I invite you to forget about “hip-openers” and to start thinking about aligning your body with integrity so that you can turn your whole yoga practice into the hip-opening experience that it’s meant to be!

~

Jenni Rawlings loves to weave her natural interest in anatomy and biomechanics into her yoga teaching. She is grateful to so many teachers who inspire her, most notably amazing biomechanist Katy Bowman. You can find out more about Jenni at www.jennirawlings.com.

——

Earlier

4 comments… add one

  • Hip Hip Hooray for your enlightening article. Love the pigeon. I work with many clients who have had hip replacements…including me. Safety first + integrity. Have a namaste!

  • yogini bunny

    thank you for this thoughtful post. I am always so grateful when people can explain anatomy in a way that is accessible. I really appreciate the pictures too. my teacher tells us to keep the natural curve in the lumbar when we do reclined pigeon, and now I fully understand why. thank you!! I look forward to reading more anatomy info from you.

  • The Reclining pigeon photo where you are resting your body weight over the bent knee is not such a great idea. The knee is a hinge joint and putting pressure on the medial side of the knee when it is bent like that increases the risk of tearing the cartilage of the knee. We need to stabilize the joints, not over-stretch them. One of best hip openers is squatting. Visit:www.yogalign.com one of the few yoga methods that focus on posture not poses.

  • Hi Joe,

    Thanks for reading! The pose you’re referring to which puts pressure on the knee is single-leg pigeon, not reclined pigeon. And yes, I did write above about how this pose puts the knee at risk – glad you agree!

Leave a Comment