by J. Brown
Despite the plausibility of good intentions, the yoga industry’s emphasis on transformation around the new year feels a bit too opportunistic. Personal transformation may come as a natural progression in the context of yoga practice but the process is greatly hindered when the concept is used as a dangling carrot to sell memberships.
Owners of yoga centers know that some welcome maximization of profits can be had by working the new years resolution angle, offering a special deal that counts on the fact that most people are not going to make good on it. But exploiting human insecurities for financial gain goes against my broader purpose. Such are the ways of a reluctant businessman.
I’m not nay-saying new years resolutions or transformation. If some change is warranted and the mental will to help bring it about can be summoned then, by all means, be bold and go forth with a true intention. However, in my experience, transformation rarely comes in a flash from some flamboyant push. Real and lasting change tends to occur in a gradual and subtle way as a result of persistent effort, often recognized only in retrospect.
Instead of touting transformation, I propose we celebrate survival.
Like the modern equivalent of a Shakespearean fool, Chris Rock astutely noted that little credit or praise is bestowed for simply “banging out the rent.” The notion of success has become so linked to an emaciated body and a bloated bank account that it becomes difficult to recognize or appreciate the many small and profoundly important feats we accomplish daily.
In last months’ consideration of The Daunting Work Before Us, I attempted to stare down life’s hardship with stark honesty and a whimsical tongue. While this may have made for some needed catharsis and empathetic reading, it did not provide much solace or inspiration.
Fortunately, I since had the pleasure of hosting a friend and fellow teacher from San Francisco named Chase Bossart. He is the co-founder of a not-for-profit organization called the Healing Yoga Foundation and a genuine scholar of Patanjali’s Yoga Sutra. He proffered that we don’t actually have as much control over what happens to us as we might like to think. In many respects, we are just along for the ride.
The suggestion is not that life is predetermined or that we have no say in the matter, only that our ability to influence events is limited. Chase compared the way yoga practice affects change to a gardener growing a tomato plant (some may remember the theme from Mind-Body Connection Optional?.)
The gardener has no way of knowing if the plant will thrive or how many tomatoes it will produce but if the seed is planted in fertile soil and tended to carefully, providing the right mix of water, light and patience then, chances are, the plant will produce more tomatoes than otherwise.
Yoga does not transform anyone. Life does that all by itself.
All we can really do is tend to our gardens and hope for the best. Some years, unforeseen drought or swarms of parasitic bugs may wreak havoc and leave us with only roots. Other years, we have abundance. Regardless, we can always plant anew. Even a skeptic like myself can’t deny that the cycle of life carries on nonetheless.
This morning, for the first time, my two year old daughter said: “I love you Daddy.” Her sweet little words of unadulterated affection left me in awe at the actuality of how things are taking place. The work ahead may be daunting but there is no doubt that the rewards, when they come, are worth our efforts. Joy behooves us to survive.
J. Brown is a yoga teacher, writer and founder of Abhyasa Yoga Center in Brooklyn, NY. His writing has been featured in Yoga Therapy in Practice, Yoga Therapy Today and the International Journal of Yoga Therapy. Visit his website at yogijbrown.com.
Recent articles by J. Brown:
- The Daunting Work Before Us: 2011 Reflections, 2012 Intentions
- Yoga Alliance Approved, My Ass
- Screw Union With the Divine
- Yoga or Advil
- Nonviolence, Hypocrisy and Veganism
More in Yogopinions.
- Is The New York Times Wrecking Yoga? The Community Responds
- Rich, Possibly Befuddled Lululemon Founder Chip Wilson Resigns After Series of Controversies
- Yoga Injuries and Battered Egos, ‘How Yoga Wrecks the Body’ via The New York Times
- Significance of 108 Sun Salutations – DO
- Compass Yoga: A New Direction for Wellness
What an interesting and different perspective – and so eloquently put. We often forget that there is something truly amazing in the ordinary.
Though I’m still planting seeds and my plants are yet to bloom, I’m going to sit in gratitude that my roots have survived so far.
Thanks for your post!
” He proffered that we don’t actually have as much control over what happens to us as we might like to think. In many respects, we are just along for the ride.”
Partly true !
Our present life is shaped partly, by the Cumulative-Karma of our Aatma, accumulated over all of the previous re-incarnations of our Aatma, and partly, by the Actions and In-actions that we CHOOSE to make in the present life.
So, it’s not ALL pre-determined. Neither is it ALL free-will.
But there is certainly a good deal of free-will granted to us.
The Voice of Conscience that we faintly hear, as we contemplate committing an act of poor-Karma, is actually our Aatma, reminding us that we HAVE indeed been granted enough free-will in this life, that we may still CHOOSE to walk away from committing that particular inglorious-act that we were contemplating, and thereby yet redeem the Cumulative-Karma of our Aatma.
“Yoga does not transform anyone. Life does that all by itself.” –
beautifully and, i also believe, truly said 😉
Transformation happens when you aren’t looking.
We are all one all from different backgrounds each have different experiences.. I need you just as much as you need me.. We are all like parts of a wheel on the outside trying to get to the center…We are all trying to have a relationship with the Great spirit!.. check out http://www.swaaggear.com practice and wear what you preach with style!